Paradigm Shifts in Coordination Theory
نویسندگان
چکیده
Coordination – commonly defined as the achievement of concerted action has been a phenomenon of central concern to organizational theorizing since the 1920s. Until the 1980s, information processing and contingency theorists have shaped coordination theory around the relationship between coordination mechanisms and drivers like task dependence, uncertainty, and equivocality. Recently, conceptual and empirical papers have emerged that offer new insights in coordination, emphasizing structures, processes and knowledge. As a field, however, coordination theory currently lacks coherence and focus. We suggest that paradigm shifts have occurred that have remained largely unknown and unaddressed. This unawareness constrains theoretical discussion and progress. A paradigm is a set of ontological and epistemological assumptions that drives theory development and ultimately empirical research. According to Kuhn (1962), discussion on a paradigmatic level is needed when theory development stagnates. The objective of this conceptual paper is to formulate and compare paradigms underpinning coordination theory. The paper distinguishes three paradigms: contingency, structure-process, and inner-outer worlds. These paradigms are tied to literature, and each applied to the same example from a sports context. Analysis of the example fosters comparison and reveals the three unique perspectives on how individuals function in a collaborative setting, and how coordination is achieved. Each paradigm contributes differently to coordination theory, and has its own strong and weak points. The paper suggests that shifting the debate on coordination theory to a paradigmatic level offers new potential for a field that is of great importance to organization theory and practice.
منابع مشابه
What Is Applied Literature?
Applied literature is a term that is the outcome of a need to put literature to tangible uses in the “real” world. A medical practitioner looking for a definition of life, for instance, finds literature a useful source for the answer. With paradigm shifts in scientific studies, interdisciplinarity has been a method to overcome the alienations that resulted from the isolation of disciplines from...
متن کاملTranscendent Medicine and Deep Medicine Paradigm
Background: Very recently, Eric Topol, a physician-scientist, introduced his “deep medicine” theory in 2019. This theory has been originated from the last two decades advancements of systems medicine and digital medicine, science and technology convergence in biological fields and formation of the precision medicine. The transcendent medicine theory that has been derived from Sadr ad-Din Shiraz...
متن کاملIntegrating Multi-agent Negotiation to Resolve Constraints in Fulfilling Supply Chain Orders
As the order fulfillment process (OFP) in supply chains shifts to outsourcing paradigm, the OFP performance relies on the coordination among supply chain partners to reach executable and effective plans. The coordination of OFP among supply chain partners can be viewed as a distributed constraint satisfaction problem (DCSP). This paper enhances the existing methods to solve the DCSP by adding t...
متن کاملThe Use of Gender Justice Paradigm in the Islamic Republic of Iran (1997-2005) from the Institutional Theory
متن کامل
Organizational Black Hole Theory
There are issues in organizations that require new theoretical formulation. Hence, metaphorical theorizing is used in the study of organizations to interpret them and understand their complexities. In this method, the organization is likened to an entity and one of the key features of that entity is generalized to the organization. It should be borne in mind that most organizational theories ar...
متن کامل